Pop-Tarts Sends Three New Edible Mascots — Including a Mystery Flavor — To The Pop-Tarts Bowl

By Heather Taylor, Editor-in-Chief, PopIcon
What’s better than one edible mascot? Three edible mascots, according to Pop-Tarts — and we’re in agreement! The Pop-Tarts Bowl is back on December 28, 2024. This time, it’s triple the Crazy Goodness with three new Edible Mascots Game Day-bound.
Meet The New Edible Mascots

Pop-Tarts fans will recall that the first Edible Mascot, Frosted Strawberry, debuted in 2024 (and was shortly consumed thereafter). The project from Weber Shandwick marked the first-ever edible mascot. Frosted Strawberry, RIP, was an instant viral hit in college football and for the Pop-Tarts brand.
Less than a year later, three new mascots are heading to the football field. They include Frosted Wild Berry, a familiar fan favorite with its purple frosting and teal swirl, and Frosted Hot Fudge Sundae, loaded with fudge and icing covered in sprinkles.

The third Edible Mascot is a Mystery Flavor. Nobody knows its identity. We can’t even get a good look since Mystery Flavor is wrapped up in the Pop-Tarts signature silver packaging.
At PopIcon, we have some guesses based off clues found in the Pop-Tarts press release.
What we know: This flavor is discontinued, beloved by fans, and frosted. (The release states there are “three new frosted faces” heading to The Pop-Tarts Bowl.)
Who could the Mystery Flavor be? We “would” place our bets on Frosted Grape, but the formerly discontinued flavor has been back for a while now. And while Peach Cobbler was quietly shelved a few years back, it feels too niche a flavor for the fans to demand back on grocery shelves.
Our guess is Mystery Flavor will be Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough. There are almost 2,000 signatures circulating on a Change.org petition to bring it back. And we do love the chaotic nature that is massive wild berry, fudge and cookie dough flavored Pop-Tarts all showing up to be devoured at a college football game.
Keep your eyes peeled to Pop-Tarts social media platforms to see who the Mystery Flavor is in the next few weeks. Catch the 2024 Pop-Tarts Bowl live on ABC December 28 at 3:30 PM EST from Orlando’s Camping World Stadium. It’s gonna be Crazy Good!
Image Credits: Kellanova
About the Author
Heather Taylor is the senior writer and editor-in-chief of PopIcon, Advertising Week’s blog about brand mascots. Got a pitch on brand mascots or want to wax nostalgic about characters? Drop her a line at howveryheather@gmail.com.
You May Also Like
Retail Media Doesn’t Need More Ad Tech, Featuring Drew Cashmore of Vantage
In this episode of Retail Media Unboxed, Drew Cashmore, Chief Strategy Officer at Vantage, explains why retail media has evolved far beyond an advertising channel into a competitive business platform.
Why the Best Brand Reps Are Starting to Look Like Educators
Marketers are shifting budget from paid media toward in-person reps because a single well-informed conversation now often outperforms another thousand impressions.
Small Businesses Embrace the Role of ‘Creator’ to Get Seen in 2026
It seems like everyone’s a creator now, and it’s not just because they want to be social media stars. It comes down to how today’s consumers shop.